Balistreri’s | Italian American Ristorante | Bluemound Inn
A longtime local favorite -- go to Italian American Ristorante on 68th Street for casual pizza or lasagna (even carry out!), or Balistreri’s Bluemound Inn a couple blocks away for a fine dining experience.
Phone See Locations
Buca di Beppo | 1233 N Van Buren • Milwaukee
Hearty portions so big that you are sure to walk out with lunch for tomorrow, Buca’s in Milwaukee serves you homestyle Italian that will fill you up right.
Phone (414) 224-8672
Zaffiro’s Pizza & Bar | 1724 N Farwell Ave • Milwaukee
An eastside legend for its delicious thin crust and flavorful toppings. Zaffiro's has (arguably) the best pizza in the entire city.
History • Menu • Information • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 289-8776
Pizzeria Piccola | 7606 W State St • Wauwatosa
This Bartolotta establishment offers specialty thin crust pizza and is especially frequented in the summer for it’s outdoor seating and live music. A much more casual Bartolotta establishment if you're craving Italian.
Menu • Information • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 443-0800
Riverfront Pizzeria Bar & Grill | 509 Erie St • Milwaukee
Located in the Third Ward on the Riverwalk, Ricardo's Riverfront Pizzeria Bar & Grill offers a full Italian menu -- but the pizza is where it’s at!
Menu • Information • Facebook
Phone (414) 277-1800
Zarletti | 741 N Milwaukee St • Milwaukee
Not too fancy, yet not overly casual, Zarletti has become a can’t miss restaurant on Milwaukee Street’s growing list of high-quality dining. The lunch and dinner menu’s are unique, and the desserts will make you want to stick around.
Menu • Information • OpenTable • Facebook
Phone (414) 225-0000
Il Mito Trattoria e Enoteca | 6913 W North Ave • Wauwatosa
Many great pasta dishes, a large wine selection and scrumptious desserts make Il Mito a destination in the Tosa area.
Menu • Information • OpenTable • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 443-1414
Mimma's Cafe | 1307 E Brady St • Milwaukee
Mimma's Cafe has served some of Milwaukee's favorite Italian food since the 1980's. Mimma's also has a good variety of wines that complement the items on their menu.
History • Menu • Information
Phone (414) 271-7337
Joey Buona's | 500 N Water St • Milwaukee
Whether you're craving family-style Italian or a pizza to share, Joey Buona's is a great choice. Located on Water & Clybourn, Joey Buona's is close to the Third Ward, Milwaukee Street and the Milwaukee River.
Menu • Information • Facebook
Phone (414) 272-8662
Ristorante Bartolotta | 7616 W State St • Wauwatosa
This charming Bartolotta's restaurant in Tosa is the perfect place for a romantic dinner or big graduation celebration. One of the most knowledgable staffs around serves authentic Italian food at it's finest.
About • Menu • Information • OpenTable • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 291-3770
Rustico | 223 N Water St • Milwaukee
Sandwiches, pastas and pizza right along the Riverwalk in Milwaukee’s trendy Third Ward.
Menu • Information • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 220-9933
The Pasta Tree | 1503 N Farwell Ave • Milwaukee
Cute little Eastside bistro is the perfect place to bring a date or celebrate an anniversary.
Menu • Information • Facebook
Phone (414) 276-8867
Venice Club | 1905 N Calhoun Rd • Brookfield
Located in the Milwaukee suburb of Brookfield, the Venice Club is a truly-Italian dining experience. Famous for their eggplant and also great for other traditional Italian dishes.
Phone (262) 786-8323
Palermo Villa | 2315 N Murray Ave • Milwaukee
Located just off North Avenue on the eastside, Palermo Villa is one of Milwaukee's best Italian/Sicilian style restaurants. You'll definitely enjoy their hand tossed Florentine pizza!
Menu • Information • Facebook
Phone (414) 278-7460
Maggiano's Little Italy | 2500 N Mayfair Rd • Wauwatosa
Not your typical chain restaurant, Maggiano's has become a Wauwatosa favorite. Located adjacent to Mayfair Mall, Maggiano's is warm and classy and serves delicious authentic Italian food.
Menu • Information • OpenTable • Facebook • Twitter
Phone (414) 978-1000
Best of: Italian Restaurants
We also recommend: American Restaurants, Mexican Restaurants
